| 1 | Mon Nov 3 | vs Louisiana | W75-64 | 1-0 | 1.000 | - | ESPN+ | Worthen Arena · Muncie, IN |
| 2 | Fri Nov 7 | vs TBD | W84-54 | 2-0 | 1.000 | - | ESPN+ | Worthen Arena · Muncie, IN |
| 3 | Tue Nov 11 | at #24Wisconsin | L55-86 | 2-1 | .667 | - | BTN | Kohl Center · Madison, WI |
| 4 | Sat Nov 15 | vs Little Rock | L62-68 | 2-2 | .500 | - | ESPN+ | Worthen Arena · Muncie, IN |
| 5 | Sat Nov 22 | at Indiana St | L52-70 | 2-3 | .400 | - | ESPN+ | Hulman Center · Terre Haute, IN |
| 6 | Fri Nov 28 | vs Monmouth | L73-80 | 2-4 | .333 | - | ESPN+ | Kirby Sports Center · Easton, PA |
| 7 | Sat Nov 29 | at Lafayette | L37-55 | 2-5 | .286 | - | ESPN+ | Kirby Sports Center · Easton, PA |
| 8 | Sun Nov 30 | vs Le Moyne | W96-85 | 3-5 | .375 | - | ESPN+ | Kirby Sports Center · Easton, PA |
| 9 | Wed Dec 3 | at Evansville | L52-64 | 3-6 | .333 | - | ESPN+ | Ford Center · Evansville, IN |
| 10 | Tue Dec 9 | vs S Dakota St | L64-68 | 3-7 | .300 | - | ESPN+ | Worthen Arena · Muncie, IN |
| 11 | Sun Dec 14 | at Campbell | L64-69 | 3-8 | .273 | - | | John W. Pope Jr. Convocation Center · Buies Creek, NC |
| 12 | Sat Dec 20 | vs Miami OH | L77-86 | 3-9 | .250 | - | ESPN+ | Worthen Arena · Muncie, IN |
| 13 | Mon Dec 29 | vs TBD | W93-30 | 4-9 | .308 | - | ESPN+ | Worthen Arena · Muncie, IN |
| 14 | Sat Jan 3 | at Buffalo | L72-85 | 4-10 | .286 | - | ESPN+ | Alumni Arena · Buffalo, NY |
| 15 | Tue Jan 6 | vs E Michigan | L52-74 | 4-11 | .267 | - | ESPN+ | Worthen Arena · Muncie, IN |
| 16 | Sat Jan 10 | at UMass | L71-79 | 4-12 | .250 | - | ESPN+ | William D. Mullins Memorial Center · Amherst, MA |
| 17 | Tue Jan 13 | at Akron | L77-87 | 4-13 | .235 | - | ESPN+ | James A. Rhodes Arena · Akron, OH |
| 18 | Fri Jan 16 | vs Ohio | W76-71 | 5-13 | .278 | - | CBSSN | Worthen Arena · Muncie, IN |
| 19 | Tue Jan 20 | at C Michigan | W68-67 | 6-13 | .316 | - | ESPN+ | McGuirk Arena · Mount Pleasant, MI |
| 20 | Sat Jan 24 | vs N Illinois | W58-53 | 7-13 | .350 | - | ESPN+ | Worthen Arena · Muncie, IN |
| 21 | Sat Jan 31 | at Toledo | L55-73 | 7-14 | .333 | - | ESPN+ | Savage Arena · Toledo, OH |
| 22 | Tue Feb 3 | at Bowling Green | L52-77 | 7-15 | .318 | - | ESPN+ | Stroh Center · Bowling Green, OH |
| 23 | Sat Feb 7 | at UL Monroe | W73-68 | 8-15 | .348 | - | ESPN+ | Fant-Ewing Coliseum · Monroe, LA |